
Jay’s Story
James “Jay” Toland was one heck of a man, and to those who knew and loved him, he was simply the best.

Jay grew up in Preston, Connecticut, with his parents, Paula and the late Tom “Tiger,” and his siblings, Tara, Shaun, and Justin. His childhood was filled with sports, laughter, mischief, and plenty of practical jokes played on unsuspecting family members. Whether he was competing in BMX bike races or playing baseball, football, or basketball, Jay was always doing something. He wasn’t one to follow the traditional path, and he had a kind of intelligence that couldn’t be measured by a diploma.

In 1998, Jay welcomed his son Hunter, his pride and joy, into the world. Jay shared an incredibly special bond with Hunter. They were not only father and son, but also best friends. Whether they were hunting together, spending time outdoors, or simply enjoying each other’s company, the two shared a closeness that was truly special. Their relationship was filled with love, laughter, friendship, and countless memories. It was a father-son bond that went far beyond words, one that Hunter will carry with him for the rest of his life.
In 2005, Jay married Karen, and together they built a life filled with memories, challenges, laughter, and love. Jay also gained a son, Tyler, and later a daughter-in-law, Ashley. He became a grandfather to Rylan and Emersyn, and although he never had the opportunity to meet his granddaughter Penelopy, she will always be part of his family’s story.

If you knew Jay, you knew exactly where he stood on just about everything. He was outspoken, opinionated, stubborn, patriotic, and never afraid to speak his mind. He was quick-witted, incredibly funny, and could be a real pain in the you-know-what! But underneath that tough exterior was a man with a heart of gold.

Jay loved hunting, especially deer and bird hunting, and treasured his time at the family hunting cabin in upstate New York. He loved playing cards, buying lottery tickets, sharing laughs with his buddies, and simply enjoying life. He made friends wherever he went, and those friendships meant the world to him. Jay was the kind of person you didn’t easily forget.
Jay was surrounded by so much love throughout his life. He had a way of making lasting friendships, and the people who knew and loved him were just as important to him as he was to them.
In April 2022, Jay made a life-changing decision to stop drinking after developing cirrhosis of the liver. It wasn’t an easy road, but he was incredibly proud of his sobriety, and he had every reason to be.

Jay was eventually placed on the liver transplant list, giving him hope for a healthier future. But in 2024, everything changed when he was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer and removed from the transplant list.
It was another devastating blow, but Jay wasn’t about to give up without a fight.
He faced his illness with the same stubborn determination that had always been part of who he was. Through the difficult days, treatments, uncertainty, and heartbreak, he continued fighting.
And he wasn’t alone.

His family, friends, and loved ones stood beside him. Hunter’s fiancée, Miranda, was among those who helped care for him during his illness. The love surrounding Jay was a reflection of the countless lives he had touched over the years.
Through Jay’s illness, the love he and Karen shared grew into something especially beautiful. In the end, what mattered most was their love and the precious time they had together. One of their most meaningful memories was Jay’s final hunting trip to the family cabin. For the first time, Karen was allowed to join him during hunting season because he was sick and needed her there. It was a place they both loved, and although neither could know for certain what lay ahead, that trip carried a special meaning. It became a memory she would treasure forever.
In December 2025, Jay lost his battle with pancreatic cancer.
He left behind a family who adored him, friends who will never forget him, countless memories, and a space in so many lives that can never truly be filled.

He was simply the best.
